The Grand Staircase (Part 1): Grand Canyon – why is there a canyon here at all?
Jon Trevelyan (UK)
This is the first of three articles following that succession upwards: from the deeply incised rocks of the Grand Canyon, through the great Mesozoic landscapes of Zion, to the much younger rocks being dismantled at Bryce Canyon.
A river in the wrong place
The Grand Canyon seems, at first sight, to require very little explanation. There is a river at the bottom and an enormous canyon around it. Rivers erode their beds; given enough time, the Colorado River cut down through the rocks of northern Arizona and produced one of the most spectacular landscapes on Earth.
But that explanation begins halfway through the story. The more interesting question is not simply how the Colorado cut the Grand Canyon. It is why the river is here at all.
The Colorado crosses the Colorado Plateau, an immense region of elevated country extending across parts of Arizona, Utah, Colorado and New Mexico. Much of the plateau stands well over a kilometre above sea level. Yet, the river does not skirt this high ground. It crosses it and, through the Grand Canyon, cuts more than 1,500 m down into an extraordinary thickness of rock (Fig. 1).

At the canyon rim, the river can seem surprisingly insignificant within the landscape it has helped to create. Between rim and river lies a succession of sedimentary rocks hundreds of millions of years old; in the Inner Gorge, incision has exposed Precambrian rocks whose history extends back towards two billion years (Fig. 2).

It is tempting to imagine a simple solution to the geographical problem. Perhaps the Colorado was already flowing across a low landscape and maintained its course while the plateau rose beneath it, cutting down quickly enough to keep pace with uplift. Rivers can sometimes behave in this way, producing what geologists call antecedent drainage.
However, the history of the Grand Canyon is not so easily explained. The modern Colorado drainage system is comparatively young and developed from earlier drainage systems, whose rivers did not necessarily follow modern routes. Some terminated in internal basins; others flowed in different directions. As the landscape changed, drainage divides migrated, basins overflowed and rivers captured neighbouring drainage.
Eventually, these separate elements became connected into a river capable of carrying water and sediment from the Rocky Mountain region, across the Colorado Plateau and towards the Gulf of California. By about 5–6 million years ago, through-flow towards the Gulf region had been established. recisely how that connection developed remains debated – and will be a central part of our story.
Nor does the comparatively young age of the integrated Colorado necessarily mean that every part of the canyon is equally young. Older rivers crossed the region, and some parts of the modern canyon may incorporate valleys or palaeocanyons inherited from earlier drainage systems. The Colorado may, therefore, have cut some reaches afresh, while elsewhere exploiting and deepening older topography.
So, instead of asking simply how long it took a river to excavate the Grand Canyon, we need to reconstruct a sequence of events. The Colorado Plateau had to be raised. Drainage had to be reorganised. Separate river systems had to become connected. The resulting Colorado had to incise deeply into the plateau, while tributaries, weathering and mass movement enlarged the canyon around it.
There is one further complication. The Kaibab Limestone forming much of the canyon rim can easily appear to mark the top of the geological succession. It does not. Younger rocks once continued above it, but have subsequently been stripped from much of the Grand Canyon region. To find substantial parts of that missing succession, we have to travel north.
Across southern Utah, younger rocks survive through the sequence of plateaus and cliffs known as the Grand Staircase. Zion exposes rocks lying higher in the regional succession than those forming much of the Grand Canyon, while still younger rocks are preserved around Bryce Canyon. Grand Canyon, Zion and Bryce are, therefore, not simply three spectacular landscapes. Together, they expose different parts of a much larger geological succession (Fig. 3).

That makes the Grand Canyon the natural place to begin our journey through the Grand Staircase – at its deepest exposed level.
However, before we can explain why the Colorado crosses this elevated landscape, we need to understand what it has cut through. The canyon walls preserve an extraordinary geological archive, from Permian rocks at the rim, to ancient crystalline rocks beside the river. And within that succession lies one of the greatest gaps in the geological record.
The rocks beneath the canyon
To descend into the Grand Canyon is to travel backwards through an extraordinary span of geological time. At the rim are rocks around 270 million years old. Beside the Colorado River in the Inner Gorge, rocks formed more than 1.7 billion years ago are exposed. Between them lies a succession recording vanished seas, coastal plains, rivers and deserts that occupied this part of North America, long before there was a Colorado Plateau, let alone a Grand Canyon.
The most immediately striking feature of the canyon walls is that the sedimentary rocks remain remarkably horizontal. From a distance, they appear as enormous coloured bands extending across the landscape. Some form sheer cliffs; others weather into gentler slopes and terraces. This alternation between resistant and weaker formations gives the canyon much of its characteristic stepped architecture (Fig. 4).

At the top is the Kaibab Limestone, the resistant Permian formation that makes up much of the canyon rim. It was deposited in a shallow sea about 270 million years ago. Beneath it, the Toroweap Formation records changing marine and coastal environments.
Below these lies the pale Coconino Sandstone, whose large-scale cross-bedding records migrating dunes in a Permian desert. The softer reddish mudstones and sandstones of the Hermit Formation beneath it were deposited in river and floodplain environments and weather preferentially into slopes. The thick reddish succession below belongs principally to the Supai Group, deposited as rivers, coastal plains and shallow seas repeatedly occupied the region. Differential erosion of these rocks produces many of the steps and ledges visible in the canyon walls.
Further down is one of the canyon’s most conspicuous cliff-forming units, the Redwall Limestone. Deposited in warm Mississippian seas roughly 340 million years ago, the limestone itself is generally grey; its familiar reddish appearance largely results from staining by material weathered from the red beds above.
Lower still, the succession eventually reaches the important Cambrian sequence of the Muav Limestone, Bright Angel Shale and Tapeats Sandstone. Together, these record the advance of a Cambrian sea across an ancient continental landscape. Sand accumulated near the advancing shoreline, followed by finer sediment and carbonate deposition, as marine conditions became established.
This succession is, therefore, much more than a pile of differently coloured rocks. It records repeated environmental change as seas advanced and retreated and deserts, rivers and coastal landscapes replaced one another through hundreds of millions of years (Fig. 5).

Nor is the record continuous. Deposition repeatedly stopped, erosion occurred and sedimentation resumed. But nothing higher in the canyon prepares us for the change beneath the Tapeats Sandstone. The orderly succession of broadly horizontal sedimentary rocks comes to an abrupt end.
In places, the Cambrian rocks rest directly on dark crystalline rocks of the Vishnu Basement Rocks. These metamorphic and igneous rocks are approximately 1.7–1.8 billion years old and record a vastly earlier stage in the development of the North American continent.
Elsewhere, another chapter survives between the crystalline basement and the Cambrian rocks. These are the Precambrian strata of the Grand Canyon Supergroup. Unlike the younger Palaeozoic succession, they have been faulted and tilted. Erosion subsequently cut across their inclined edges, before the Cambrian sediments were deposited above them.
The contrast is fundamental. Above are comparatively regular Palaeozoic strata; below are much older rocks recording deformation, metamorphism, faulting, tilting and erosion before that younger succession was deposited (Fig. 6).

The Colorado has, therefore, exposed a geological archive spanning an immense interval of Earth history. Yet one of its most remarkable features is something that is not preserved. Between the Precambrian rocks and the Cambrian succession, enormous stretches of geological time are missing. In places, rocks separated in age by more than a billion years lie almost directly against one another. The surface between them is part of the Great Unconformity – and it is where our story goes next.
A billion years missing
There are few places where the incompleteness of the geological record can be appreciated as dramatically as in the Grand Canyon. Its walls seem at first to offer an almost continuous history, with layer after layer descending towards the Colorado River.
In reality, enormous intervals of time are missing. The most spectacular example is the Great Unconformity. In places, Cambrian sedimentary rocks a little over 500 million years old rest directly on crystalline rocks formed around 1.7 billion years ago. A boundary that can be crossed in a single step may, therefore, separate rocks whose histories are more than a billion years apart.
An unconformity is a break in the geological record. Sediment may not have accumulated for a prolonged period; previously existing rocks may have been eroded; or both processes may have occurred before deposition eventually resumed. At the Great Unconformity, that missing history is on an extraordinary scale (Fig. 7).

The rocks beneath this surface show that a great deal happened before the Cambrian sea arrived. The oldest exposed rocks belong to the Vishnu Basement Rocks, including metamorphosed sedimentary and volcanic rocks intruded by younger granitic bodies. Their history extends back roughly 1.7–1.8 billion years, when crustal fragments and volcanic arcs were being assembled along the growing margin of Laurentia, the ancient continental nucleus of North America.
These rocks were buried, metamorphosed, deformed and intruded at considerable depth before uplift and erosion eventually brought them towards the surface (Fig. 8).

In parts of the canyon, a younger Precambrian succession survives above the crystalline basement. The Grand Canyon Supergroup, deposited mainly between about 1.25 billion and 730 million years ago, contains sedimentary and volcanic rocks formed in ancient basins. These strata were subsequently faulted and tilted.
Then erosion took over. The tilted rocks were truncated and, in some places, removed completely. Much later, during the Cambrian, the sea advanced across this ancient landscape and deposited the sediments that include the Tapeats Sandstone. This is why the Great Unconformity does not everywhere bring the same rocks together. In some places, horizontal Cambrian strata rest across the eroded edges of tilted Grand Canyon Supergroup rocks. Elsewhere, where the Supergroup had been removed, they lie directly on crystalline basement.
The physical boundary itself can appear remarkably insignificant compared with the quantity of time it represents. There is no empty space corresponding to the missing years. Two rocks simply meet (see box: The Great Unconformity: What is missing?).
A billion years can be represented by a line.
| The Great Unconformity: What is missing? |
|---|
| Few geological surfaces are as celebrated as the Great Unconformity, spectacularly exposed in the Grand Canyon. Its importance lies not in what is present, but in what is absent. In places, Cambrian sedimentary rocks about 525 million years old rest directly on crystalline basement roughly 1.7 billion years old. More than a billion years of Earth history is, therefore, unrepresented at the contact. Elsewhere, younger Precambrian rocks of the Grand Canyon Supergroup intervene. These were deposited, tilted and eroded before the Cambrian sea advanced across the region, so horizontal Cambrian strata lie across the truncated edges of much older inclined beds. The Great Unconformity is, therefore, not everywhere exactly the same rock-on-rock contact. It is a regionally extensive erosional surface recording an extraordinary sequence of events: formation of ancient continental crust, deposition and deformation of younger Precambrian rocks, prolonged erosion and, finally, burial beneath Cambrian sediments. Nor does the missing interval necessarily represent continuous erosion. For much of that immense span, sediment may simply not have accumulated, while rocks deposited at other times may subsequently have been removed. The result is one of geology’s most dramatic omissions: hundreds of millions to more than a billion years represented by a surface that can sometimes be crossed in a single step. |
Why so much time is missing is a larger question than the Grand Canyon alone. Great Precambrian–Cambrian unconformities occur across extensive areas, and their origins remain debated. Long periods of uplift and erosion associated with the assembly and breakup of the supercontinent Rodinia probably contributed, while intense erosion associated with late Precambrian glaciations has also been proposed as an important influence.
For our story, the essential point is simpler. Long before the Colorado River existed, this region had already undergone repeated episodes of construction, deformation and destruction. The Grand Canyon exposes that ancient history, because erosion by the Colorado and its tributaries has cut deeply enough to reach it.
However, the Great Unconformity and the rocks on either side explain what the canyon has cut through. They do not explain why a canyon was cut here. For that, we must jump forward hundreds of millions of years. The younger sedimentary succession was eventually carried to elevations far above sea level, while remaining, remarkably, comparatively little deformed across much of the region. The next part of the story is, therefore, the raising of the Colorado Plateau.
Raising the Colorado Plateau
The Grand Canyon presents a geographical problem as much as a geological one. The Colorado River does not simply cross a low plain and happen to encounter a thick succession of sedimentary rocks. It cuts through the Colorado Plateau, a vast region of elevated country extending across parts of Arizona, Utah, Colorado and New Mexico.
Much of the plateau lies between about 1,500m and 2,500m above sea level, with still higher areas around its margins. Yet, across enormous areas, its sedimentary rocks remain remarkably close to horizontal. That combination – great elevation, but comparatively little deformation – is one of the defining characteristics of the Colorado Plateau.
The contrast with the surrounding regions is striking. To the east rise the Rocky Mountains. To the west, the Basin and Range Province has been stretched and broken into fault-bounded ranges and basins. Between these more strongly deformed regions, the Colorado Plateau has behaved comparatively like a coherent block.
It is not completely undeformed. Faults, folds, broad warps and particularly impressive monoclines occur across the plateau. Nevertheless, its rocks have largely escaped the intense folding and faulting characteristic of many major mountain belts (Fig. 9).

This unusual relationship is represented schematically in Fig. 10.

How did such a large region get so high? There is no single simple answer. An important stage occurred during the Laramide Orogeny, beginning in Late Cretaceous time and continuing into the early Cenozoic. This mountain-building episode profoundly reorganised western North America, producing many of the structures associated with the Rocky Mountains and affecting areas unusually far inland from the continental margin.
The ultimate cause lay beneath western North America. For much of the Mesozoic, the oceanic Farallon Plate was being subducted beneath the continent. During the Laramide, at least part of the descending slab appears to have become unusually shallow. This flat-slab subduction transmitted compressional stresses far into the continental interior, uplifting basement blocks, creating basins and reorganising the landscape.
The Colorado Plateau participated in this deformation, but remained unusually coherent. Ancient basement structures were locally reactivated, helping to produce some of the monoclines now visible at the surface, but the plateau was not crumpled into a conventional mountain chain.
Nor did changes in elevation necessarily end with the Laramide. Significant topographic change continued during the Cenozoic, and precisely when different parts of the plateau acquired their present elevations remains debated. Proposed influences include changes in the thickness and buoyancy of the lithosphere, modification or removal of dense mantle lithosphere beneath the region, and broader tectonic changes following fragmentation of the Farallon Plate.
Different processes may have operated at different times and beneath different parts of the plateau. Reconstructing that history is difficult, because the elevation of an ancient landscape cannot simply be read from the height of its rocks today. Uplift, burial, erosion and exhumation can all alter the relationship between a rock and sea level. Researchers have, therefore, drawn on evidence, including ancient river gradients, volcanic and carbonate deposits, fossil plants and thermochronology, sometimes reaching different conclusions.
For the Grand Canyon story, however, we do not need to resolve every detail. The crucial point is that, by the time the modern Colorado drainage system emerged, it was crossing a region that had already undergone enormous tectonic and topographic change.
This returns us to the paradox with which we began. If the Colorado were much older than the uplift, we could envisage an established river maintaining its course, while the land slowly rose beneath it, eroding downwards quickly enough to remain in place. Such an antecedent river would provide a comparatively straightforward explanation for a deep canyon crossing high ground.
But the modern Colorado drainage system does not appear to be old enough for that simple explanation. Earlier rivers followed different routes. Some terminated in internal basins; others drained towards destinations very different from those of today. The upper and lower Colorado were not always parts of a single river. In substantial part, therefore, the elevated landscape was already there before the modern through-flowing Colorado was assembled.
That is the problem represented by Fig. 3 (above). The plateau is high. Beneath its surface lies an enormous thickness of sedimentary rock resting on ancient basement. Rivers cross parts of the landscape, but there is not yet necessarily one continuous Colorado River following the route of the modern Grand Canyon.
Somehow, those separate drainage systems had to become connected. That is why saying simply that “the Colorado River carved the Grand Canyon” explains much less than it appears to. Before there could be a Grand Canyon, there first had to be a Colorado River.
Where did the Colorado River come from?
Today, the Colorado River appears to be an obvious geographical feature. From its headwaters in the Rocky Mountains, it flows south-westwards across the Colorado Plateau, through a succession of deep canyons and eventually towards the Gulf of California. On a modern map, it looks like a single integrated river system.
Geologically, it was anything but inevitable. Rivers crossed parts of the Colorado Plateau long before the modern Colorado existed, but they did not necessarily follow its present course or even flow in the same direction. Some terminated in internal basins; others drained away from the Grand Canyon region altogether. An ancestral river in the Colorado region is, therefore, not necessarily the ancestral Colorado River.
During the later Cenozoic, drainage across the American Southwest was repeatedly reorganised. To the west, extension created the Basin and Range Province, with fault-bounded mountains separated by subsiding basins. Further south and west, development of the San Andreas system and opening of the Gulf of California altered the regional geography and provided new potential outlets for rivers.
On and around the Colorado Plateau, rivers draining the southern Rocky Mountains and other uplands formed elements of what would eventually become the upper Colorado system. Their earlier courses remain incompletely reconstructed, and some water probably flowed into internal basins or along routes subsequently abandoned.
Further southwest, the lower Colorado was developing separately through the Basin and Range. Here, early drainage encountered a succession of basins separated by uplands, rather than one continuous valley leading towards the sea. Water and sediment could accumulate within a basin until an outlet developed into the next.
Evidence for this history survives in deposits along the lower Colorado corridor. Particularly important is the Bouse Formation, deposited in bodies of water occupying several of these basins, while the lower drainage system was developing. Precisely how some of these deposits should be interpreted remains debated, but they provide evidence of the changing geography through which the lower Colorado emerged.
The important point is that the lower river was not simply the downstream continuation of an already established upper Colorado. For a time, there were effectively two geographical problems: an upper drainage system on and around the plateau and a developing lower system further southwest. Between them lay drainage divides, internally drained basins and the region through which the Grand Canyon would eventually develop.
Somehow, those systems became connected. Several processes could have contributed. Headward erosion can extend a drainage system progressively upstream, until it breaches a divide and captures water that previously flowed elsewhere. Spillover can occur when water accumulating in a basin rises sufficiently to cross a low divide, establishing an outlet that subsequent erosion enlarges.
These mechanisms need not have been alternatives. Capture, basin filling, spillover and changing regional gradients could have interacted, with different processes operating in different parts of the developing river system (Fig. 11).

The Colorado is, therefore, better envisaged as a river assembled from previously separate pieces, than as one ancient river gradually extending along its modern course.
Sediment provides an important constraint on when that assembly had occurred. Mineral grains eroded from particular source regions can be transported downstream and incorporated into younger deposits. Finding Colorado-derived sediment far downstream, therefore, demonstrates that a drainage connection existed.
By roughly 5–6 million years ago, sediment from the Colorado system was reaching the developing Gulf of California region. Whatever the precise sequence of events further upstream, an integrated river capable of carrying material from the Colorado Plateau towards the Gulf had emerged by then.
That gives us an important age for the modern drainage system. It does not give us a birthday for every part of the Grand Canyon. Older valleys may already have existed along parts of the eventual route. Some may have carried rivers in different directions; some may have been abandoned or partly filled before being re-excavated. Other reaches may have been cut afresh, when previously separate drainage systems became connected.
We will return to that problem when considering the disputed age of the canyon itself. For the moment, the essential point is simpler. The upper drainage existed. The lower drainage existed. The elevated Colorado Plateau lay between them. What did not yet exist was the connection. The next stage in the story is, therefore, how those separate rivers and basins became joined into a single through-flowing Colorado River.
Joining the rivers together
At some point in the late Miocene or earliest Pliocene, the geography of the American Southwest crossed an important threshold. Drainage systems that had previously remained separate, became sufficiently connected to establish through-flow across the Colorado Plateau and towards the Gulf of California. The modern Colorado River had begun to emerge.
The previous section introduced the principal mechanisms that may have contributed: headward erosion and river capture, together with basin filling and spillover. We do not need to envisage one process operating everywhere. Different parts of the developing river system may have been joined in different ways.
In river capture, a drainage network extends progressively upstream until erosion breaches a divide and intercepts neighbouring drainage. Water that formerly flowed elsewhere is diverted into the expanding river system, and the additional discharge can help enlarge and entrench the new route.
Spillover provides another mechanism. Rivers flowing into an enclosed basin may create a lake, whose level rises until water crosses the lowest part of the surrounding divide. Once overflow begins, erosion can lower the outlet and establish permanent drainage into the next basin. Repeated spillover can, therefore, link a succession of formerly separate basins.
The developing lower Colorado appears to have involved complicated basin-to-basin drainage evolution of this kind, although important details remain debated. The Bouse Formation records bodies of water occupying basins along the lower Colorado corridor during this period, but interpretations of their precise environments and relationship to river integration have varied.
The broad sequence, however, is clearer than many of its details. Sediment derived from the Colorado Plateau was reaching the developing Gulf of California region by approximately 5–6 million years ago. By then, the upper and lower parts of the drainage system must have become sufficiently connected for sediment to travel from the plateau towards this new regional outlet.
Once that connection existed, its consequences were profound. A river terminating in an internal basin can erode only towards the level imposed by that basin. Connecting the Colorado drainage to substantially lower country towards the Gulf provided a new regional base level. The integrated river could adjust to that lower outlet. It could cut down.
As the Colorado incised, its tributaries also had to adjust. Lowering of the main channel left tributary mouths above the new river level, increasing their gradients and encouraging them to cut down in turn. Erosion, therefore, spread through the developing drainage network.
This did not mean that the Grand Canyon suddenly appeared when through-flow was established. Excavation was prolonged, and the new river may have encountered an inherited landscape containing older valleys and considerable relief. Nor should the drainage integration shown in Fig. 4 (above) be imagined as a single event progressing neatly upstream from the Gulf. Capture may have mattered in one area, spillover in another, while pre-existing valleys could have guided the river elsewhere. What eventually emerged was a network assembled from existing and newly created connections.
Establishing an integrated Colorado River and establishing the age of the Grand Canyon are, therefore, not quite the same problem. If through-flow was present by about 5–6 million years ago, does that mean the Grand Canyon itself is only 5–6 million years old?
For many years, something close to that seemed the simplest answer. Evidence from the canyon has since made the question considerably more complicated.
When was the Grand Canyon born?
Ask how old the Grand Canyon is and the obvious expectation is that geology should provide a date. It does not. The difficulty begins with deciding exactly what is being dated. Do we mean the first valley cut anywhere along the route of the modern canyon? The first deep canyon? The establishment of a continuous Colorado River? Or the development of something recognisably like the landscape we see today?
Those need not have happened at the same time. For much of the twentieth century, a comparatively young Grand Canyon provided the simplest interpretation. We have already seen that an integrated Colorado was carrying water and sediment towards the Gulf of California region by about 5–6 million years ago. Much of the canyon’s deep incision appears to have occurred during the comparatively short interval since then.
Other evidence, however, has suggested that parts of the story may be considerably older (see box: How do you date a canyon?).
| How do you date a canyon? |
|---|
| A canyon cannot usually be dated like a lava flow or volcanic ash bed. Its excavation is a process, rather than a single event, so geologists have to reconstruct its history indirectly. Thermochronology uses minerals within rocks to investigate when those rocks cooled, as erosion brought them closer to the surface. Apatite fission-track and uranium-thorium/helium dating have both been used to reconstruct the erosional history of the Grand Canyon region. Caves provide another clock. As a river cuts down and the regional water table falls, former cave passages can be abandoned high above the active groundwater system. Mineral deposits within them can sometimes be dated and used to constrain incision. River gravels and other sediments can reveal former river levels and drainage routes, while their composition may identify the source regions from which sediment was transported. Volcanic rocks can show that a canyon already existed when lava entered it and may constrain subsequent incision. Finally, downstream sediments can reveal when formerly separate drainage systems became connected. These methods do not date precisely the same event. One may record cooling and exhumation, another local river incision and another the establishment of through-flow hundreds of kilometres away. Apparently different ages may, therefore, refer to different stages in the development of the landscape. |
Thermochronology has played a particularly important role in the debate. Rocks become cooler, as erosion removes overlying material and brings them closer to the surface. Minerals such as apatite can retain evidence of this cooling, allowing researchers to reconstruct aspects of their burial and exhumation history.
Some studies have been interpreted as indicating substantial erosion or canyon cutting tens of millions of years before the modern Colorado developed. At its strongest, the resulting old-canyon hypothesis proposed that substantial canyon segments might have existed by around 70 million years ago. That raises an obvious problem. How can a canyon be tens of millions of years older than the river flowing through it?
One possible answer is that it was not originally the same canyon. Earlier rivers crossed the Colorado Plateau along different routes. They could have excavated valleys or palaeocanyons along parts of the route later occupied by the Colorado. Such valleys might subsequently have been abandoned, partly filled with sediment or incorporated into different drainage systems before being reused by the younger river (Fig. 12).

The important distinction is, therefore, between the age of an individual piece of topography and the age of the continuous Grand Canyon. An older valley could be incorporated into a much younger drainage system without requiring the entire canyon to be equally old (see box: Old canyon or young canyon?).
| Old canyon or young canyon? |
|---|
| The traditional interpretation of the Grand Canyon emphasises its comparatively young history. An integrated Colorado River was delivering water and sediment towards the Gulf of California region by about 5–6 million years ago, and much of the canyon’s deep incision appears to have occurred since then. Thermochronological studies, however, have been interpreted by some researchers as evidence that significant palaeocanyons existed along parts of the modern route, tens of millions of years earlier. The apparent disagreement partly depends on what is meant by the “age of the Grand Canyon”. It could mean: the age of an individual canyon segment; the age of a continuous canyon across the Colorado Plateau;the arrival of the modern Colorado River; or the development of the broadly recognisable landscape seen today. These need not have happened simultaneously. One possible reconciliation is that the modern Grand Canyon is a composite landscape. Older rivers may have excavated valleys along parts of its eventual route. Much later, integration of the Colorado could have connected, deepened and modified these inherited features while cutting new reaches between them. The existence, age and extent of such ancient canyon segments remain debated. A much firmer constraint is that an integrated Colorado River was reaching the Gulf of California region by about 5–6 million years ago. The river, in other words, may be younger than parts of the landscape through which it flows. |
This interpretation is not universally accepted. Thermochronology records thermal history, rather than canyon excavation directly, and cooling can result from broad regional erosion, as well as the cutting of a confined valley. Reconstructed histories also depend on assumptions about burial depths, geothermal conditions and subsequent erosion. Independent evidence is, therefore, important (Fig. 13).

Caves can constrain stages in river incision, while volcanic rocks, river gravels and sediment-filled palaeovalleys provide other pieces of the history. Lava that entered an existing canyon, for example, demonstrates that substantial relief was already present when the eruption occurred. No single piece of evidence, therefore, provides a universal birthday for the Grand Canyon (Fig. 14).

The most useful picture is, therefore, of a landscape whose different reaches may have had different earlier histories, before becoming parts of the same river system. Some may preserve elements of older drainage; others may have been cut predominantly after integration of the Colorado. The contrasting landscapes in Fig. 14 remind us that the canyon is not uniform along its length, although their appearance alone tells us nothing certain about their relative ages.
What is much firmer is that, by around 5–6 million years ago, the through-flowing Colorado had become connected towards the Gulf of California. From then on, the river possessed a continuous downstream route and a much lower regional base level. Whatever valleys it inherited, and whatever reaches it had to excavate afresh, it could now cut deeply into the Colorado Plateau.
The next question is, therefore, not when the first valley appeared. It is how the Colorado cut down so far, so fast.
Cutting down
Once an integrated Colorado River had established a route across the plateau, the problem changed. The river no longer had to find a continuous path towards lower country. It already possessed one. Now, it could deepen it.
The scale of the resulting incision is extraordinary. From parts of the South Rim to the Colorado River, the vertical difference exceeds 1,500 m. The river has cut through the entire Palaeozoic succession and, in the Inner Gorge, into Precambrian rocks more than 1.7 billion years old. Yet the Colorado itself can appear remarkably small when seen from the rim. How could such a river cut so deeply into the plateau?
The first requirement is relief. Rivers erode because water moves downhill under gravity. Connecting the Colorado drainage towards the Gulf of California provided access to a much lower regional base level than the internal basins into which some earlier rivers had drained. The river’s profile could adjust to that lower outlet, and the effects of that adjustment could propagate upstream.
The Colorado began to incise. Flowing water alone, however, is only part of the erosional machinery. A sediment-laden river is a powerful cutting tool. Sand and gravel abrade the bed, while cobbles and boulders mobilised during floods grind and strike exposed rock. Turbulent water exploits joints and fractures, loosening material that can then be transported downstream.
Much of this work is episodic. Ordinary flows may be unable to move the largest material in the channel, whereas major floods can mobilise boulders, reorganise gravel bars and scour bedrock. Repeated over geological time, such events contribute substantially to incision.
The rocks themselves also influence the process. Resistant sandstone and limestone behave differently from weaker shale and mudstone, while faults, joints and other fractures provide weaknesses that erosion can exploit. Incision has, therefore, varied through both space and time, rather than proceeding at a uniform rate.
Nor does adjustment occur simultaneously along an entire river. Changes in base level can create steeper reaches or knickpoints that migrate upstream, concentrating erosion as they go. Tributaries respond as well: as the Colorado lowers its bed, their mouths are left at a higher relative elevation and they begin cutting down towards the new level. Incision by the trunk river can, therefore, trigger erosion throughout its tributary network (Fig. 15).

The early stages in Fig. 15 emphasise an important distinction. Downcutting can initially produce a relatively narrow entrenched gorge. The much broader landscape that we recognise as the Grand Canyon develops as erosion spreads outwards from it – a process we will examine in the next section.
Continued changes in regional elevation may also have helped maintain the river’s erosive potential. We should not imagine the plateau first being raised to its full modern height and the Colorado only then beginning to cut into a static landscape. Uplift, drainage reorganisation and incision overlapped, and their relative importance varied across the region.
Nor, as we saw in the previous section, was the newly integrated Colorado necessarily cutting everywhere into an untouched plateau. Inherited valleys or palaeocanyons may have guided the river through some reaches, while new connecting gorges had to be excavated elsewhere. However, once a channel had become established, continued incision could preserve surprisingly complicated features of its earlier course (Fig. 16).

Horseshoe Bend illustrates an important principle. A deeply entrenched river course need not have originated in a landscape resembling the one through which it flows today. A channel established on a much less deeply dissected surface can retain its general pattern, as erosion carries it progressively downwards into the underlying rocks. That helps explain the depth of the Grand Canyon. But it does not explain its extraordinary width.
The Colorado occupies only a narrow strip at the bottom of an erosional landscape that may extend for many kilometres between the rims. Downcutting by the main river established the depth and base level of the canyon system, but it could not by itself have excavated that enormous space. For that, we must turn from the river to the canyon walls and tributaries. The Colorado cut down.
The landscape followed.
Making a canyon wider
Seen from the rim, the Grand Canyon presents an extraordinary mismatch of scale. Far below is the Colorado River, a narrow ribbon of water. Around it is an immense landscape of cliffs, terraces, ridges, buttes and branching side canyons extending many kilometres from the river.
The Colorado plainly did not excavate all of that space simply by eroding its bed and banks. As we saw in the previous section, incision by the main river established the depth and base level of the canyon system. Widening required erosion to spread outwards from that deeply entrenched trunk river.
Tributaries played a central role. As the Colorado lowered its bed, tributaries adjusted to the lower level at their mouths by cutting down themselves. That erosion worked progressively upstream, extending side canyons further into the plateau. Major tributaries acquired smaller tributaries of their own, producing an increasingly intricate drainage network (Fig. 17).

Streams, however, are only part of the process. Once erosion creates steep canyon walls, weathering and gravity begin to dismantle them. The alternating resistant and weaker formations described earlier are particularly important. Strong sandstones and limestones can maintain steep cliffs, while softer mudstones and shales weather more readily into slopes. As a weaker formation retreats, the resistant rock above may become unsupported until blocks break away.
Sometimes this produces individual rockfalls. At other times, much larger sections of a canyon wall fail as landslides. Repeated over thousands and millions of years, such failures allow cliffs to retreat progressively into the plateau. The resulting debris commonly accumulates as talus beneath the cliffs (Fig. 18).

For the canyon to continue enlarging, this fallen material ultimately has to be removed. Weathering breaks debris into smaller fragments, while rainfall, runoff and further mass movement carry it into gullies and tributaries. The drainage network then transports it towards the Colorado, which provides the final route out of the canyon system.
The familiar cliff-and-slope architecture of the Grand Canyon, therefore, reflects both stratigraphy and erosion. Resistant formations retreat differently from weaker ones, producing the stepped profile visible throughout the canyon. The rocks determine how the landscape responds, as erosion progressively dissects it.
Buttes and mesas demonstrate the same process particularly clearly. They did not rise from the canyon floor. They are erosional remnants – pieces of a formerly more continuous succession left behind as the rocks surrounding them were removed (Fig. 19).

The same principle applies to the canyon as a whole. Much of the enormous space between its rims was once occupied by rock. Today’s cliffs, ridges and buttes are what remains after erosion removed much of the formerly continuous succession around them.
Widening has not occurred everywhere at the same rate. Rock type and structure influence erosion, while faults and fractures can provide local weaknesses. Climate affects rainfall, runoff, weathering and vegetation. Landslides may temporarily obstruct drainage, whereas floods can rapidly remove sediment that accumulated over much longer periods. The resulting landscape is inevitably irregular. Figure 5 (above) simplifies the process into a sequence, but in reality, countless tributaries, cliffs and slopes have evolved simultaneously.
And they are still evolving. Rockfalls continue, tributaries transport sediment, and canyon walls weather and retreat. The Colorado still removes and redistributes material, although dams upstream have substantially altered its natural flow and sediment regime. On human timescales, most of these changes are small, but their cumulative effect over geological time is enormous.
The Grand Canyon is, therefore, much more than a trench cut by the Colorado. The river established the through-going drainage route and deepened it; tributaries extended erosion into the plateau; weathering and gravity dismantled the canyon walls; and the drainage network carried the debris away.
The canyon grew both downwards and sideways.
Yet even this describes only the removal of rocks from beneath the present plateau surface. Look upwards towards the Kaibab Limestone at the rim and it is tempting to imagine that we have reached the top of the geological succession. We have not. A great thickness of younger rock once continued above the Grand Canyon – and that missing part of the story leads us northwards towards the rest of the Grand Staircase.
The rocks that have disappeared
Standing on the rim of the Grand Canyon, it is easy to imagine that the Kaibab Limestone represents the top of the geological succession. Below it, layer after layer descends towards the Colorado River. Above it is simply sky. Geologically, however, the sky is full of missing rock.
The Permian Kaibab Limestone, about 270 million years old, is merely the youngest major formation preserved across much of the Grand Canyon rim. Sedimentation in this part of western North America did not end there. During the Triassic, Jurassic and Cretaceous periods, enormous quantities of additional sediment accumulated across the region. Most of those younger rocks have subsequently been stripped away from the Grand Canyon area (Fig. 20).

This missing succession should not be confused with the Great Unconformity encountered much deeper in the canyon. There, an ancient erosional surface separates rocks, whose ages may differ by more than a billion years. Above the present rim, by contrast, we are dealing principally with younger strata that were deposited and later removed as the landscape was uplifted and eroded.
Their disappearance is important because the present rim is, therefore, an erosional surface, not the original top of the sedimentary pile. Fortunately, the missing rocks have not vanished everywhere. Travel north from the Grand Canyon into southern Utah and progressively younger parts of the regional succession are preserved. This relationship produces the sequence of plateaus and cliffs known as the Grand Staircase.
Figure 3 (above) introduced that relationship at the beginning of this article. The Grand Canyon exposes the deepest and oldest part of our three-part journey. Around Zion, younger rocks survive above the broad stratigraphic level represented by the Grand Canyon rim. Further north again, still younger rocks are preserved around Bryce Canyon.
The relationship is not a literal staircase in which precisely the same unbroken stack of formations once extended everywhere across the entire region. Deposition, erosion and local geological history varied through space and time. But as a broad regional framework, travelling from Grand Canyon to Zion and then Bryce takes us progressively upwards through younger parts of the geological record.
That change records an extraordinary succession of vanished landscapes. Triassic rivers, floodplains and deserts were followed by Jurassic environments that included the immense dune fields represented by the Navajo Sandstone around Zion. Still younger rocks eventually accumulated above them, including the Cenozoic strata from which the landscapes of Bryce Canyon would much later be carved (see box: Where did the missing Grand Staircase go?).
| Where did the missing Grand Staircase go? |
|---|
| The Kaibab Limestone at the Grand Canyon rim is about 270 million years old, but it was not the last rock deposited across the region. Younger Triassic, Jurassic and Cretaceous strata once continued above it. Much of that younger cover has subsequently been removed from the Grand Canyon area by erosion. Parts of the succession survive further north, however. This is the basis of the Grand Staircase: moving broadly northwards from Grand Canyon through Zion towards Bryce takes us progressively upwards into younger rocks. The relationship should not be interpreted as an exact layer-for-layer stack that once extended unchanged across the whole region. Individual formations vary laterally and some disappear altogether. Nevertheless, the regional pattern is clear. The rocks now exposed at the Grand Canyon rim were once buried beneath younger strata. Before the modern canyon could be cut, much of that overlying cover had already been removed. The missing rocks are, therefore, part of the Grand Canyon story, as well as the link to the landscapes further north. |
This long history of stripping also complicates attempts to reconstruct the ancient Colorado Plateau. The present surface is the product of repeated episodes of deposition, uplift and erosion. Rocks now exposed at the rim were once buried beneath a substantial younger cover, and the elevation of today’s landscape cannot simply be projected backwards through time.
Much of that regional denudation also predates the modern Colorado River. The river did not begin with the complete younger succession still sitting above the Kaibab Limestone and then excavate everything down to the present canyon. By the time the integrated Colorado developed, an enormous amount of earlier erosion had already reshaped the region.
This gives us an important distinction. The Grand Canyon is a comparatively young erosional feature superimposed on a landscape with a vastly longer history. The rocks through which it cuts had already experienced burial, uplift and extensive erosion before the modern Colorado became established.
And the rocks missing above its rim provide the link to the next stage of our journey. At the Grand Canyon, we have descended through hundreds of millions of years of sedimentary history and reached Precambrian basement beside the Colorado. To continue upwards through the younger part of the succession, we must leave the canyon and travel north. There, the rocks begin to climb towards Zion and Bryce. The Grand Canyon is, therefore, not the end of the geological story. It is the bottom of the Grand Staircase.
The bottom of the Grand Staircase
The Grand Canyon is often described as a geological history book. Begin beside the Colorado River and climb towards the rim, and you pass upwards through hundreds of millions of years of Earth history. That description is useful, but it misses the more remarkable question that has run through this article.
Why is there a canyon here?
The answer begins long before there was a Colorado River. Ancient continental crust formed, was metamorphosed and intruded, and was later exposed by erosion. Younger Precambrian rocks accumulated above it, were faulted and tilted, and were themselves eroded. Then came the Cambrian seas and, over hundreds of millions of years, changing marine, coastal, river and desert environments.
Together, they produced the immense succession of rocks now exposed in the canyon walls. Much later, that succession was raised as part of the Colorado Plateau, while remaining remarkably little deformed across much of the region.
But uplift alone did not make the Grand Canyon. The drainage system also had to be assembled. Rivers that had once belonged to separate systems became connected as the landscape evolved. By about 5–6 million years ago, an integrated Colorado was carrying water and sediment across the region towards the Gulf of California.
Even that does not give the Grand Canyon a simple birthday. Some reaches may incorporate valleys or palaeocanyons inherited from older drainage systems, while others were cut largely after integration of the Colorado. The modern canyon may, therefore, combine pieces of landscapes with different histories.
However, once through-flow had been established, the Colorado could incise deeply into the plateau. Its tributaries responded to the falling base level, extending erosion away from the trunk river. Weathering weakened the canyon walls; rockfalls and landslides carried material downslope; streams transported the debris towards the Colorado and ultimately out of the canyon system.
The Colorado established much of the canyon’s depth. The surrounding erosional system produced much of its extraordinary width. Yet, there is one final part of the answer, and it lies above our heads.
The Kaibab Limestone at the rim is not the original top of the regional succession. Younger rocks once continued above it and were stripped away before and during the long development of the modern landscape. The Grand Canyon, therefore, records only part of the enormous volume of rock removed from this region.
What we see today is what remains. That brings us back to Figure 1 (above) and to the larger journey of which the Grand Canyon forms the first part. Rocks largely missing above the canyon survive further north, where progressively younger parts of the regional succession become major landscape-forming units.
The Grand Canyon is, therefore, more than an isolated chasm cut by a powerful river. It is the product of a much longer sequence: construction of ancient continental crust, deposition and erosion, uplift of the Colorado Plateau, reorganisation and integration of drainage, deep river incision, and continued enlargement by tributaries, weathering and mass movement. The Colorado River is indispensable to the story.
But the river alone is not the explanation.
And the geological journey does not end at the canyon rim. From the Permian rocks of the Grand Canyon, we now turn northwards and climb into younger Triassic and Jurassic strata. There, one formation in particular transforms the landscape: the immense cross-bedded sandstones of a vanished desert, whose dunes once spread across a vast area of western North America. They form some of the greatest cliffs in the American Southwest.
Part 2 takes us to Zion – and the next great step upwards through the Grand Staircase.
| OTHER PARTS IN THIS SERIES |
|---|
| The Grand Staircase (Part 1): Grand Canyon – why is there a canyon here at all? |
| COMING SOON |
| The Grand Staircase (Part 2): Zion — how a desert became a landscape of cliffs and canyons |
| The Grand Staircase (Part 3): Bryce Canyon — how do you build a forest of stone? |
